After testing over 175 pillows, bedding experts weigh in on the best options for every fill preference, sleep position and budget.
Start by thinking about your sleep position: Pillows for side sleepers should be thicker and firmer; pillows for stomach sleepers should be softer and thinner; pillows for back sleepers can fall somewhere in between.
The Coop Home Goods Original Adjustable Pillow is our top-tested recommendation for most sleepers. It kept its shape in our Lab tests and was a reviewer favorite for feeling comfortable and supportive in every sleep position. And because it's adjustable, you can create your perfect height.
When testing pillows, some of the key factors that we take into consideration include loft (or height), firmness, temperature, and value for money – as well as the sleeping position of the person we are recommending the pillow to (whether that be on their side, back or a combination of the two).
For instance, if you sleep on your side, you may want something with a bit more loft. And if you’re someone who is prone to overheating at night, it’s important to be aware that some pillows – particularly memory foam ones – may feel warmer than others. Different sleepers will get on better with different pillows, and it’s important to bear that in mind when testing.
Where relevant, we also take into account other aspects including trial periods, washable covers and extra features – such as adjustable and ergonomic designs – all of which can play a part in our recommendations.